The Journal of Bio-Intelligence (JBI) relies on expert peer reviewers to ensure the quality, originality, scientific validity, and ethical integrity of published research.
Reviewer Responsibilities: Reviewers must provide objective, evidence-based, constructive, and timely evaluations. They should accept assignments only when they have relevant expertise, sufficient time, and no conflicts of interest.
Confidentiality: Manuscripts, data, and review materials must remain confidential. Reviewers must not share unpublished information or use it for personal or professional advantage.
Conflicts of Interest: Actual, potential, or perceived conflicts must be disclosed promptly. Reviewers should decline assignments when impartiality may be compromised.
Evaluation Criteria: Reviewers should assess relevance to the journal's scope, originality, methodology, data quality, statistical analysis, reproducibility, interpretation, presentation, references, and ethical compliance.
Research Ethics: Suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, image manipulation, inappropriate authorship, missing ethical approvals, or other misconduct should be reported confidentially to the editor.
Constructive Feedback: Comments should be respectful, specific, and actionable, distinguishing major concerns from minor suggestions. Personal criticism, discriminatory language, unsupported allegations, and unnecessary citation requests should be avoided.
Editorial Recommendations: Reviewers may recommend acceptance, minor revisions, major revisions, or rejection. Final decisions rest with the Editor-in-Chief or assigned handling editor.
Revised Manuscripts: Reviewers should assess whether previous concerns have been addressed and focus on unresolved scientific issues.
Artificial Intelligence: Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or related materials to public AI systems. Any permitted AI-assisted use must protect confidentiality, and reviewers remain responsible for their assessments.
Timeliness and Recognition: Reviewers should respond promptly to invitations and meet agreed deadlines. JBI may offer reviewing certificates, acknowledgment letters, or other recognition, subject to confidentiality and reviewer consent where applicable.
Editorial Communication: Confidential concerns about misconduct, conflicts of interest, or serious scientific flaws should be communicated directly to the handling editor.
Compliance: By accepting a review invitation, reviewers agree to follow these guidelines and the Journal's applicable peer-review, publication ethics, and conflict-of-interest policies.
JBI values reviewers' contributions to fair, rigorous, and ethical peer review and to maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record.